Praying Mantis Confidential

Kim Eierman

Kim Eierman

Founder of EcoBeneficial!

Available for virtual and in-person landscape consulting, talks and classes.

Buy a copy of
The Pollinator Victory Garden!

Get the Latest Buzz

Subscribe to EcoBeneficial Updates and get your free download of:
Top 20 Ways to Create an EcoBeneficial Landscape
Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.
European Mantis011

Most of us hold the Praying Mantis and other Mantises in high regard – highly beneficial insects in our landscapes, valued as voracious predators of insect pests.  They are fascinating creatures that charm even those people who are squeamish about “bugs.”

We have put Mantises on an “insect pedestal” wishfully thinking that they are protected by some state or federal laws. In reality, no such laws exist. But, we still treasure them in our landscapes.   Sadly, we don’t have very many native Mantis species in the U.S. – only about 20 species and they don’t seem to be doing very well.

Not all Mantises are the same, in fact, some are problematic introduced species that may be doing more harm than good in our landscapes.   Thanks to a query from another native plant geek, I decided to get the inside scoop on these creatures.

Mike Crewe, Program Director at the Cape May Bird Observatory in Cape May, New Jersey has been a keen observer of exotic Mantises for some time and has blogged about them in “A View From the Cape.”   Mike shared his observations and insights with me in a recent interview.

Mike explained that are three introduced species of Mantises (noted below) that appear to be displacing the native Carolina Mantis (Stagmomantis Carolina) in his region.  These three exotic species were brought to the U.S. many years ago to help with pest management in agriculture and in home landscapes.

The European Mantis (Mantis religiosa) and the Chinese Mantis (Tenodera sinensis) were introduced in the late 1800s and the Narrow-winged Mantis (Tenodera angustipennis) was introduced in the 1930s. The European Mantis is of equivalent size as the native Carolina Mantis; the other two are significantly larger and are quite capable of catching and killing hummingbirds (some truly horrifying photos can be found with a Google search).

While the native Carolina Mantis is content to find its prey in low, shrubby areas, the introduced species are fond of flowers and will sit and wait on top of  your perennials for a juicy meal which might consist of a beneficial insect, a valuable pollinator like a native bee, or perhaps a delectable butterfly.

Mike shares this cautionary tale of what happens when exotic species are introduced, and he gives the excellent advice never to buy beneficial insects.  Learn more in the accompanying video or podcast.

Happy planting from Kim Eierman at Ecobeneficial!

Photo: European Mantis (Mantis religiosa)
Photo credit: Mike Crewe

More from EcoBlog

Dwarf Nativars – Do They Measure Up?

For those of us with small landscapes, dwarf cultivars of native plants can seem like a gift from heaven.  Want to grow a particular native plant, but just don’t have the room?  Have a straight species plant, like a native viburnum, that needs a pollinator partner for fruit production –…

Read More

Holiday Gift Ideas with a Native Gardening Twist

Enough with the ugly sweaters, run-of-the-mill Amazon gift cards, overpriced fruit-of-the-month club, and belly-bomber fruitcake!  Why not give the gardeners you love a gift that they will love?  The gift of native gardening! Here are some ideas for your holiday shopping: 1) Membership to a Native Plant Society No matter…

Read More

Bee Hotels or Natural Habitat?

There is a huge wave of enthusiasm for bee hotels and that’s totally understandable – we all want to help native bees that are facing incredible challenges. A landscape with lots of pollinator-friendly flowers is an important forage buffet, but a landscape that also provide areas for pollinators to nest,…

Read More