Host Plants: Feeding Caterpillars = Building Butterflies
Many homeowners and landscapers don’t realize the futility of just planting exotic nectar plants to support butterflies. Caterpillars of butterflies have evolved with specific host plants on which they depend. Some caterpillars use a very limited number of native host plants, some have the ability to use a wider range of plants. Caterpillars typically eat a small portion of the host plant’s leaves. It’s an important food web relationship in our ecosystems. No host plants mean no adult butterflies.
Monarch butterflies are often used as an example of this relationship, as their caterpillars have evolved to feed only on Milkweed species (Asclepias). You would think that planting any member of the plant family Asclepiadaceae would be great for Monarchs. Not so. It gets tricky with introduced, non-native species.
In the late 1800s Black Swallow Wort (Cynanchum louiseae) was introduced from Europe as an ornamental plant. It is a member of the plant family Asclepiadaceae. Black Swallow Wort is thought to have escaped from a botanical garden in Cambridge, Massachusetts. It has now invaded natural areas in Pennsylvania, New York, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Maine, Michigan, Wisconsin, California and several other states.
It turns out that Monarch caterpillars which feed on Black Swallow Wort have a mortality rate of about 100%. Why is Black Swallow Wort so bad for Monarchs, given that it is a member of the Asclepiadaceae family? Monarch caterpillars simply have not evolved with the toxins in the plant’s leaves. Adult Monarch butterflies are “tricked” by the plant believing that they are laying eggs on an appropriate caterpillar food source, not realizing that their caterpillars are doomed.
Lesson learned? What you plant matters!
Plant regionally native plant which have evolved in our ecological food webs from Kim Eierman at EcoBeneficial!
Photo: Tim Spira from the Dept of Biological Sciences at Clemson showing a Pipevine Swallowtail and the native host plant it has evolved with, Pipevine (aka Dutchman’s Pipe) Aristolochia macrophylla.
Photo by Kim Eierman
Check out Tim Spira’s book: “Wildflowers and Plant Communities of the Southern Appalachians.”
More from EcoBlog
Biodiversity is critical to the health of ecosystems but species diversity is crashing and getting worse in the face of climate change. How can you help? Skip the clones of native plants (grown from cuttings or tissue culture) and plant native seeds to increase genetic diversity to support our challenged…Read More
Book Review from The American Gardener: The Pollinator Victory Garden: Win the War on Pollinator Decline with Ecological Gardening Kim Eierman, Quarry Books, Beverly, MA. 160 pages. Publisher’s price, paperback: $26.99 Having worked as a garden designer for 15 years, I’m aware of the importance of native plants, but communicating…Read More
For those of us with small landscapes, dwarf cultivars of native plants can seem like a gift from heaven. Want to grow a particular native plant, but just don’t have the room? Have a straight species plant, like a native viburnum, that needs a pollinator partner for fruit production –…Read More